What is the Future of Heating in the UK?

It is estimated that 85% of UK households are connected to the national grid gas network, with a significant majority of those households relying on natural gas fired boilers, which collectively are estimated to produce approximately double the carbon emissions as the UK’s entire natural gas power stations combined.

There is certainly no question that we must shift away from reliance on fossil fuels to power and heat buildings in order to minimise climate change, but whilst there are clear and ongoing efforts to decarbonise electricity supplies (including the adoption of renewal technologies including wind, solar and nuclear), it seems less obvious how we will successfully shift our reliance on fossil fuels used to heat our homes. Despite the uncertainty, the UK Government is committed to achieving net carbon zero by 2050, with one key element likely to include a ban on new gas boilers which could happen as early as 2025. Here we therefore examine some of the low carbon alternatives that may become prevalent in homes as a result.

Energy efficiency in the kitchen
Heat Pumps
What is a heat pump?

Heat pumps are an established technology that work by extracting heat either from the air, water or ground, which is then transferred to be used in another location. The heat generated is then used either to warm air directly (for example in an air-to-air system), or more commonly used to heat water (for example in an air-to-water system). This is then used in water supplies and heating systems. Here we focus on air source heat pumps (ASHP’s) which are increasingly being used in homes and are generally lower cost than ground and water source heat pumps.

How does a heat pump work?

ASHP’s work in a similar way to a fridge which extracts heat from the internal compartment and discharges it into the air. Heat pumps do this in reverse, extracting heat from the air outside then putting it to use in your home. Heat pumps have a lower heat output than conventional gas boilers and therefore aren’t as effective at providing a quick blast of heat, but instead work best when heating a home slowly (maintaining a consistent ambient temperature) and they work particularly well with underfloor heating systems.

What are the advantages of Heat Pumps?
  • Improved energy efficiency and lower environmental impact.
  • Air source heat pumps can allow you to save money on energy bills.
  • You could generate additional income using the Government’s Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI) scheme which pays a tariff for energy generated with certain types of systems (currently only ground-to-water and air-to-water heat pumps are eligible for the domestic RHI scheme).
What are the disadvantages of Heat Pumps?
  • Heat pumps can require buildings to be well insulated to maintain a comfortable ambient temperature during cold periods.
  • Air source heat pumps make some noise. This is generally minimal, particularly with more modern systems, however it may be a consideration depending on where the heat pump can be positioned.
  • A heat pump will need to be positioned outside your home. They take up some space and will be visible which can make them less appealing to some. A typical unit might be approximately 1 metre (width) x 1 metre (height) x 40cm (depth).
  • Air source heat pumps can be costly to install and might require new infrastructure to be installed inside your home. This could include a water tank and larger radiators due to their lower efficiency. A typical heat pump might cost approximately £4,000-£7,500, which combined with installation costs might take the total to £6,000-£10,000.
  • Less efficient in cold weather (which is when you need them most).
Hydrogen Boilers

Hydrogen boilers are tipped as one possible solution to cut carbon emissions from heating systems. Hydrogen boilers work in a similar way to conventional gas boilers by heating water via combustion, but they burn hydrogen gas instead of natural gas. Burning hydrogen gas doesn’t produce Carbon Dioxide (one of the main greenhouse gases) and its use is therefore promoted to be ‘green’. Hydrogen gas would be distributed in much the same way as natural gas via the grid gas network and piped directly into your home.

Using hydrogen to power boilers is currently at a relatively early stage, however many boilers now sold are ‘hydrogen ready’, with the intention that these will be ready to use if and when gas networks switch over. The reality is that any move to hydrogen is likely to be phased, starting with a shift to natural gas/hydrogen blend (initially expected to be roughly 80% natural gas and 20% hydrogen). Most existing boilers should continue to work without requiring any alterations. Trials are currently underway to test this, including a recent trial by Keele University (HyDeploy) which successfully supplied a blended gas mix to approximately 30 university buildings and 100 homes over an 18 month period up to Spring 2021. It’s suggested that the introduction of blended supplies that incorporate hydrogen may happen across the national grid gas network by as early as 2025. The UK Government has estimated that hydrogen could generate a 9% reduction in carbon emissions by 2032 when compared with 2018 levels.

Notwithstanding this, the green credentials of hydrogen use are however questioned by some. Whilst the end-use of hydrogen may be greener than natural gas, hydrogen can still produce harmful nitrogen oxide (NO), despite not releasing CO2. Furthermore, there are questions over the production methods for hydrogen gas and some suggestions that the net result may be no better than continued use of fossil fuels. There are a range of ‘types’ of hydrogen gas, which ultimately differ by the way they are generated. Types include grey, blue and green hydrogen:

  • Grey hydrogen – produced from natural gas. The process used to extract and produce grey hydrogen is known to release significant amounts of Carbon Dioxide.
  • Blue hydrogen – blue hydrogen is produced using similar methods to grey hydrogen, however the process also utilises carbon capture technology to minimise the release of harmful greenhouse gases. Despite the promising concept, the process has come under scrutiny, with recent findings suggesting that the carbon capture process itself emits significant emissions, whilst there is also significant leakage of high levels of methane gas. It has therefore been suggested that the use of blue hydrogen might not currently offer any real improvement on continued use of natural gas.
  • Green hydrogen – green hydrogen is produced using water, and electricity generated using renewable sources. The production process is emission free, however it is costly and not used widely at present.
What are the benefits of using hydrogen gas to power boilers?
  • Hydrogen boilers are intended to be ‘green’ and cut carbon emissions.
  • Hydrogen boilers can utilise existing infrastructure inside your home including radiators and pipework. In the case of a blended hydrogen/natural gas mix, your existing boiler may also work without requiring any alternations.
  • Many boilers now sold are ‘hydrogen ready’ and will therefore be ready to use with hydrogen gas.
  • The national grid gas network is able to support the supply of hydrogen gas to homes, meaning that it would be piped to your home in the same way as your current natural gas supply.
What are the disadvantages of using hydrogen gas to power boilers?
  • There are questions over how ‘green’ hydrogen really is due to gases released in the gas production process and during combustion.
  • Hydrogen gas is known to be highly flammable and some people may be concerned about safety.
  • In some cases, boilers might not be ‘hydrogen ready’ and may require alterations for use with the gas.
  • Hydrogen ready boilers may increase the cost of new boilers.
Electric Radiators

Electric powered radiators have regularly been used in flats and apartments for a long time, where they are generally required to heat small, well-insulated spaces, and where installing multiple gas powered central heating systems for each flat would be costly. The use of electric radiators in traditional houses has however been limited, largely driven by the efficiency of gas versus electric systems, and the higher running costs associated with electric. That said, over recent years electric radiators have become more efficient and offer an increasingly attractive option, particularly with the flexibility and control provided when combined with smart control systems.

What are the Advantages of Electric Radiators?

  • Low maintenance in contrast to central heating systems or air source heat pumps.
  • Easy to operate and control on a room-by-room basis, allowing you to heat your home efficiently, save energy and minimise cost. With each radiator containing an in-built thermostat, temperature can be controlled accurately and areas in your home can be ‘zoned’ and heated to suit your requirements.
  • ‘Smart’ technology and phone apps can be used to control your system, including when you’re not home.
  • Modern electric radiators are quick to heat up and therefore deliver heat when you need them.
  • Electric radiators are efficient, converting almost 100% of the energy they use into usable heat. Their green credentials are improved further when powered directly by renewable energy sources such solar or wind, or by ensuring that you are using a green energy tariff.
  • Easy installation – Unlike central heating which requires underfloor pipework running between radiators and a boiler, electric radiators can be easily connected to existing electrical wiring by a qualified electrician.
  • Aesthetics – modern electric radiators come in many shapes, sizes and styles to suit your taste.

What are the Disadvantages of Electric Radiators?

  • Electric radiators can be expensive to operate as units of electricity are more expensive than units of gas (the average cost of electricity in the UK is 14.37p per kWh (unit) and 3.80p per kWh (unit) of gas. It might however be possible to partially offset this by the additional control and therefore efficiency that an electric system can provide (for example if working from home during the day, you may only need to heat one room rather than the whole house).
  • The cost of installation can be high, particularly when combined with removal of an old gas central heating system.
  • System capacity – electric heating uses a high electrical load. When considering installation of an electric heating system it is important therefore to ensure that your existing electrical systems have sufficient capacity and will not be overloaded. A qualified electrician should advise you on this.

Running Cost Comparison

Running Costs of a Conventional Gas Boiler

Conventional gas boilers tend to range in output from approximately 15kW though to 40kW. The size required will depend on factors such as the number of radiators and showers in your home. As an approximate guide, a 15-24kW boiler might be suitable for a house with 10 radiators and a single bathroom, a 30kW boiler might heat 15 radiators, and a 35-40kW boiler might be required for a larger home with approximately 20 radiators.

  • 24kW boiler - A boiler rated at 24kW will use 24kWh (units) of gas per hour. Based on an average unit price of 3.80 pence, the running cost would be £0.91 per hour.
  • 30kW boiler - A boiler rated at 30W will use 30kWh (units) of gas per hour. Based on an average unit price of 3.80 pence, the running cost would be £1.14 per hour.
  • 40kW boiler - A boiler rated at 24kW will use 24kWh (units) of gas per hour. Based on an average unit price of 3.80 pence, the running cost would be £1.52 per hour.

Running Costs of Electric Radiators

Electric radiators come in many sizes with varying power ratings. In a typical home, hard-wired electrical radiators might range from 500w (0.5 kW) – 2,000w (2kW).

To calculate the running cost of a single electric radiator, multiply its power rating (kW) by the price per unit of electricity, which you can find on your energy bill. Based on an average unit price of 14.37 pence and a radiator with a power rating of 1kW (1,000w), the hourly running cost would be 14.37 pence per hour.

  • Powering 10 radiators each with a 1kW power output will cost £1.44 per hour.
  • Powering 15 radiators each with a 1kW power output will cost £2.15 per hour.
  • Powering 20 radiators each with a 1kW power output will cost £2.88 per hour.

The above is of course a simplified example, and the reality is that an electric radiator system would include radiators of varying sizes to fit each room which should be programmed to come on only as and when needed.

Summary

It’s clear that there are still huge challenges in decarbonisation of heating systems which currently remain heavily reliant on natural gas. It seems likely that heat pumps will become widely adopted in new homes where these can be installed relatively easily during the construction period. One of the greatest challenges however lies with improving existing housing stock, given that improvements are often costly and require intrusive works to be undertaken. What is clear however it that there will be increasing pressure to shift to greener systems throughout the 2020’s on beyond.

What is the future of heating in the UK? was last modified: November 2nd, 2021 by admin

Share this Post